American Idol Season 11: Top 12.....Top 11: Birth Year Songs
Well let me start off by saying how much I DISLIKE this theme and they manage to put it in there every season. Something just seems pointless about this theme for me. But then again, the contestants really seem to have fun with it. I created a separate post to discuss the scandal so I won't go into it here. Here is how I rate the contestants tonight: Heejun Han - Right Here Waiting: A breathy out of control mess! Seriously, I think that you have not delivered one solid performance yet. It is time to do so sir!! This is the Top 11/12 and I need to see why the judges let you get this far and why America is keeping you this show. What you have shown us so far does not validate anything. I understand the tone of your voice is great but you don't have any breathing, phrasing, or control technique. Get it together or go home! Shannon Magrane - One Sweet Day: I think it comes down to the fact that she is too amateurish for this stage of the competition. She is trying to tackle songs t...