AMERICAN IDOL 9: TOP 9 Elvis Week
9. Andrew Garcia - Hound Dog: NO!!!!! What were you thinking? The arrangement was so horrible. Your vocals were lazy and lacked any kind of stability. I did not like it at all. Just a terrible performance from you. It was one of those performances that will definitely get you sent home. Please don't become the Scott Savol of season 9.
8. Casey James - Lawdy, Miss Clawdy: I don't get the appeal for this guy. His vocals are annoying and he is never vocally stable. I always forget about him and he just dissipates after every show. I am starting to hope that his time is up tomorrow.
7. Tim Urban - Can't Help Falling In Love: This was okay for me. Not super great but not horridly wrong. I honestly hope that you don't go home tomorrow. I see progression. I didn't want to see it but it is there. Now only if your vocals weren't that boring and plain.
6. Katie Stevens - Baby What You Want Me To Do: Hmm... I want to like her. I really do BUT it is like she is trying to be a singer that she is not. She has a good voice but I feel like she is trying so hard right now. She is overdoing it a little. That is just my opinion.
5. Aaron Kelly - Blue Suede Shoes: This was an improvement over last week. It was solid. That is pretty much all that I can say. Your vocals seem to be getting stronger as your confidence is
building.
4. Lee Dewyze - Little Less Conversation: MUCH BETTER than last week. At least, you were in the vocal pocket. I just don't know if you are the American Idol. I feel like you are a combination of watching David Cook, Chris Daughtry, and Kris Allen. Those 3 guys are separate but for some reason I see a little bit of them in each of your performances. Not a bad thing but definitely not a good thing.
3. Siobhan Magnus - Suspicious Minds: You just can't deny her vocals. Her pure voice is amazing. I am a fan. I know that this was Elvis week but I wish that she would sing some Leona Lewis. Their vocals are similar. Back to this performance, it was pretty good. I loved it.
2. Michael Lynche - In The Ghetto: YES!!!! This was good. He has such a great voice. As a singer, I tend to listen to females but Big Mike is a great singer. He stripped it down and took his time with it. I don't like his cockiness or his attitude but his vocals cover it very well. I am glad that they used the save on him (Even though I thought is was an act).
1. Crystal Bowersox - Saved: YES!!!! I love her so much. This was such a great performance. It was so natural. So raw and real and fearless. It is always good when you make me like a song that I have never heard of before. Kudos!!!!!
Well, I hope that my bottom 2 will be the ones going home. I doubt it for one of them though. I am sure that Andrew Garcia will be packing tomorrow. It is a definite toss up for the other spot. Katie Stevens, Siobhan Magnus, Aaron Kelly, Lee Dewyze, and Tim Urban all have targets on their backs. I am going out on a limb and saying that Katie Stevens gets the other axe tomorrow.
8. Casey James - Lawdy, Miss Clawdy: I don't get the appeal for this guy. His vocals are annoying and he is never vocally stable. I always forget about him and he just dissipates after every show. I am starting to hope that his time is up tomorrow.
7. Tim Urban - Can't Help Falling In Love: This was okay for me. Not super great but not horridly wrong. I honestly hope that you don't go home tomorrow. I see progression. I didn't want to see it but it is there. Now only if your vocals weren't that boring and plain.
6. Katie Stevens - Baby What You Want Me To Do: Hmm... I want to like her. I really do BUT it is like she is trying to be a singer that she is not. She has a good voice but I feel like she is trying so hard right now. She is overdoing it a little. That is just my opinion.
5. Aaron Kelly - Blue Suede Shoes: This was an improvement over last week. It was solid. That is pretty much all that I can say. Your vocals seem to be getting stronger as your confidence is
building.
4. Lee Dewyze - Little Less Conversation: MUCH BETTER than last week. At least, you were in the vocal pocket. I just don't know if you are the American Idol. I feel like you are a combination of watching David Cook, Chris Daughtry, and Kris Allen. Those 3 guys are separate but for some reason I see a little bit of them in each of your performances. Not a bad thing but definitely not a good thing.
3. Siobhan Magnus - Suspicious Minds: You just can't deny her vocals. Her pure voice is amazing. I am a fan. I know that this was Elvis week but I wish that she would sing some Leona Lewis. Their vocals are similar. Back to this performance, it was pretty good. I loved it.
2. Michael Lynche - In The Ghetto: YES!!!! This was good. He has such a great voice. As a singer, I tend to listen to females but Big Mike is a great singer. He stripped it down and took his time with it. I don't like his cockiness or his attitude but his vocals cover it very well. I am glad that they used the save on him (Even though I thought is was an act).
1. Crystal Bowersox - Saved: YES!!!! I love her so much. This was such a great performance. It was so natural. So raw and real and fearless. It is always good when you make me like a song that I have never heard of before. Kudos!!!!!
Well, I hope that my bottom 2 will be the ones going home. I doubt it for one of them though. I am sure that Andrew Garcia will be packing tomorrow. It is a definite toss up for the other spot. Katie Stevens, Siobhan Magnus, Aaron Kelly, Lee Dewyze, and Tim Urban all have targets on their backs. I am going out on a limb and saying that Katie Stevens gets the other axe tomorrow.
Comments